×
What's new

The power of a great arrangement

Nekujak

My muse is demanding better working hours
I recently watched a movie that included the old Turtles song, "You Showed Me", in the soundtrack. I always liked this song, but had completely forgotten about it until I heard it again in the movie.

As I was looking for the song on the web, I was surprised to discover it had originally been done by the Byrds (written by Gene Clark and Jim McGuinn). The song itself has tons of potential - it's got a great melody, interesting chord changes, alluring lyrics - but this version is rather uninspired, and doesn't do anything to grab the listener nor make you want to hear it again:



But when the Turtles got ahold of it a few years later, their super cool arrangement (which kind of happened by accident) emphasized the song's best attributes and elevated it into something magical:



Later in the 1990s, the Lightning Seeds had a minor hit with their cover, adding a hip hop beat and using samples from the Turtles version. It appeared in the first Austin Powers movie, and is faithful to the Turtles version, but the updated beat gives it a more modern feel:



Salt n Peppa put their own spin on the song, with a full-on hip hop/rap version:



Madison Beer covered it a few years ago, taking cues from the Turtles version. You just can't keep a good song down:




Just one of many examples out there of a decent song that's transformed into something truly great through a creative and imaginative arrangement.

Have a happy day!
 
Hi @Nekujak - the song "Without You" which has a rather tragic story associated with it, was originally written and recorded by members of the group Badfinger. Their version pales in comparison to the hit Harry Nilsson had with it with it's full on orchestral arrangement... one of my favourite songs ever...
 
I loved the Lightning Seeds' version of "You showed me" because of its dreamy quality, and I really like Ian Broudie's voice. I didn't know Madison Beer but I quite like her version too. The Salt'N Peppa one is fun and groovy.

And sometimes a great song can even survive a truly atrocious version...well...almost:

This song was a european club and chart hit in 1992. The singer's voice is nice but the arrangement is so generic... And why that Depeche Mode sample on a Patti Smith cover?


(I also noticed that the guys miming to the sample in the video seem to be singing "It's a love" when the sample says "It's a lot" :unsure:)
 
Back
Top Bottom